Content

Post new topic Reply to topic
<<  1, 2

Testing a new sig I made (WoW)

Author Message
Japieja Beard with a Conscious View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Decision wrote :

Japieja wrote : You beautimus alliance scum Very Happy



Horde are just sad because they lack paladins Sad



Hehe paladins IS the class why I didnt pick alliance... you know what they say right? Bubble+HS Razz

Decision View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Forza wrote :

Japieja wrote : hehhe, no man.. Troll Shamaaaan!!

Anyways, lets not get offtopic now... just like in the 'I was' Razz



Yea sorry Razz

I think the pics are badly blended and the font doesn't look good. The size is not appealing.



It fits the forum they're being posted in.

Another one I'm working on..



(Why so many paladins!)

Icarus View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

I don't see how the font, and the picture blending has anything to do with a forum background.

Decision View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Icarus wrote : I don't see how the font, and the picture blending has anything to do with a forum background.



The forum's default background color, the size of most sigs in the forum, there are more things to list, but do I need to justify myself considering it's my artwork and I like it for my own reasons.





Icarus View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Decision wrote :

Icarus wrote : I don't see how the font, and the picture blending has anything to do with a forum background.



The forum's default background color, the size of most sigs in the forum, there are more things to list, but do I need to justify myself considering it's my artwork and I like it for my own reasons.



Ahem.

Decision wrote :

Forza wrote :

Japieja wrote : hehhe, no man.. Troll Shamaaaan!!

Anyways, lets not get offtopic now... just like in the 'I was' Razz



Yea sorry Razz

I think the pics are badly blended and the font doesn't look good. The size is not appealing.



It fits the forum they're being posted in.

Another one I'm working on..



(Why so many paladins!)



He mentioned the poor picture blending and the size. He didn't say a thing about the white background you got going there, and IN HIS OPINION the sig is too big, which he probably meant without the white around it.

Also, you're posting them here for crits so take them instead of saying you don't have to justify yourself, and that it's your artwork (which is debatable, seeing as I wouldn't define ripping 3d models from a game and pasting them into a banner artwork, but that's just me).

Decision View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

"you're posting them here for crits so take them instead of saying you don't have to justify yourself."

What I was referring to was the fact that their overall style fitting the forum I was posting in would be completely out of context for him. If you really want to check it out I can post a screenshot of the forum, sorry for any mixup on my part.


In terms of size I agree they are rather large how I posted them, I have resized them all since to no more than 135 pixels tall.

I appreciate the feedback so far.

Japieja Beard with a Conscious View user's profile Send private message

Reply with quote Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Here's some feedback for ya..

Remove the beautimus Palladin and place a nice troll shaman in it Very Happy

<<  1, 2
Post new topic Reply to topic

Online
0 / 2472